Every city has its families. Every family has its rules. And in this one… the rule is good pizza, no compromises.
Fat Tony's Pizza was built on old-school values — respect the dough, honor the sauce, and never serve something you wouldn't put on your own table. We keep it simple, the way New York intended: thin crust, proper cheese pull, and flavors that don't ask for permission.
This isn't fast food.
This is family business.
We believe pizza should be folded, not forked. Baked hot, served straight, and remembered long after the box is gone. No gimmicks. No shortcuts. Just NY-style pizza done the right way.
Thin crust NY-style pizza, made with respect for the craft. Every pie comes out of the oven the way it should — hot, honest, and ready to be folded.
Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or feeding the whole crew, we deliver the same quality every single time.
Welcome to Fat Tony's Pizza.
You eat with us — you're family.
Follow the family. Join the crew.
Catering for the crew? A custom pie for a special occasion? Large orders for events? We handle business — just tell us what you need.
Make a Request